A Christmas Carol is my favorite book, and “though it has never put a scrap of gold or silver in my pocket,” I try to objectively grade every film adaptation of the book on its faithfulness to the source material. So when I learned that Ti West was making yet another contribution to this stack of films, I knew I had to check it out.
I watched Ebenezer, so (you can decide if) you don’t have to. This post is rife with spoilers. You’ve been warned.
However, I have NOT run this film through my full process. I watched this movie in a theatre, like a normal person. I wasn’t checking it against my spreadsheet in real time. So you’ll have to wait until it hits streaming for me to give it an official score like the others.
Ebenezer is vexing, but not all bad
This film makes some ABSOLUTELY UNHINGED choices. (“I will not gainsay it, Spirit. God forbid!”) If we hold it up against the book, we are going to get a lot of very weird feelings. When I watched it, I felt a lot more “Huh?” than “Naw.”
My thoughts on the movie aren’t all negative. It does an unusually swell job at:
- Nodding to the great films that have come before
- Handling the characters of Nephew Fred and Little Fan
- Generally hitting the beats of the story (61% of the book’s beats are included)
However, Ebenezer makes some bizarre moves:
- “Virtue fraud” is rampant in this movie. Beggars fake infirmaries, charity workers illegally acquire funds, close family members steal inheritances … and worse?!
- GONE are the tenderness of the Ghost of Christmas Past, the joviality of the Ghost of Christmas Present, and the mystery of the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come. These may as well be different characters entirely.
- Horror is turned way up; merriment is turned way down. There is more of grave than of gravy about this film!
OK. Let’s get into it.
Ebenezer is NOT the worst film adaptation of A Christmas Carol
Do I love this movie? No. But I don’t think all the hate it’s already getting is entirely merited—at least from a faithfulness standpoint.
The book coverage is good. In general, the movie covers the whole story of the book. (It even preserves the “stave” chapter markers in title cards.) Many of Ebenezer‘s omissions are common to film adaptations: Scrooge doesn’t wonder what time it is as he awaits the Ghost of Christmas Past, Caroline doesn’t rejoice at her creditor’s passing, and we don’t visit the mining colony, the lighthouse, or the ship at sea. I’ll talk more about the weird, significant omissions later—but overall, this movie covers the book’s story beats fairly well.
Ebenezer does Nephew Fred justice. Fred is kind. Fred is warm. Fred is persistent. Fred is open-hearted. And above all, Fred is important. Fred retains most of his lines from the book when he meets Scrooge at the counting house. Fred expresses genuine pity for Scrooge at his Christmas party (which the movie moves to Christmas Eve). And this movie gives Scrooge and Fred far more time together in the finale than any other film, I believe. Of all the film adaptations I’ve reviewed, this is probably in my top 3 in terms of Fred treatment. It may even go out of its way to shine the character: Fred donates to a panhandler in Stave One, and he doesn’t use Scrooge as an answer in the game of “Yes and No” in Stave Three. But given how overlooked and underplayed Fred can be in film adaptations (looking at you, Muppets), it was refreshing to see a film treat him like this.
Ebenezer might have the best treatment of Little Fan. In the book, Scrooge’s sister Fan only occupies a few paragraphs. In movies, she’s either given entirely new scenes or cut out entirely. But Ebenezer gives the character her full place in the story: she’s the only person who shows warmth to child Scrooge on Christmas, and memories of her instigate Scrooge’s journey back to treating Fred like family. Sure, Ebenezer‘s treatment isn’t perfect: Fan is older than Ebenezer (instead of younger), and the movie turns on the water works when it comes to Fred remembering her. But hey, this is the ONLY movie I’ve seen that directly connects Fred’s wife’s music to memories of Little Fan. That’s an extremely deep cut, and I have to give West kudos for it.
Ebenezer seems aware of the Christmas Carol movie greats. The giants’ shoulders are recognized throughout the film. Fred’s wife (whom Dickens leaves unnamed) is Clara—a reference to The Muppet Christmas Carol. When asked what made Scrooge change his mind about visiting Fred, Scrooge simply replies, “Christmas”—mirroring Tiny Tim’s annoying seer-like dialogue in Scrooge (1951) starring Alastair Sim. Belle is seen working at a debtor’s prison, another pull from Scrooge. Young adult Scrooge merrily courts Belle, like he does in the 1970 musical starring Albert Finney. It might be a stretch, but even the skeletal body horror of the Ghost of Christmas Past’s onscreen decay might be a nod to the 2009 Jim Carrey film.
I guesstimate Ebenezer will fall in the middle of the pack when I give it the full treatment next year.
Where Ebenezer goes wrong
For all its strong points, this movie makes some choices that seem to contradict the point of the book, and some that are just distractingly weird. Let’s start with the weird stuff.
Weird: The Christmas Ghosts are damned, too
West made the very interesting choice to make all the ghosts in this movie the same sort of ghost Marley is: they’re all paying for the sins they committed in life. The Ghost of Christmas Past didn’t value the time she had. The Ghost of Christmas Present just wants to stuff his face. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is … dead Scrooge?! Somehow, they’ve all been conscripted to show Scrooge a few vignettes apiece, and they make it clear they don’t really care if Scrooge is any better off for it.
I don’t need to explore how contrary these ideas are to the original. You get it. I’m more weirded out by the choice itself. It creates so many questions that go unanswered. If Marley is chained to his money boxes and ledgers, why are these other ghosts chained to Scrooge? How is the Ghost of Christmas Past so well-versed in Scrooge’s history? Why does the Ghost of Christmas Present get to die after one day? Why would Want and Ignorance cling to him? And how the blazes is Scrooge being visited by his own alternate-future ghost self?! I mean, COME ON.
I hate that I’m even suggesting this, but this entire movie would have made so much more sense without the three Christmas ghosts. Marley could have simply ushered Scrooge through the entire journey in macabre fashion, providing commentary actually informed by his knowledge of Scrooge.
Weird (and sad): Christmas is not very merry
I get it: this is a ghost story. It’s supposed to be scary. But for crying out loud, where is the jolliness? The novella has plenty of dark content, but it also includes a great deal of merriment, even in the face of hard times and bad weather.
Ebenezer leaves most of this out. Bob doesn’t slide on the ice with the London youths. The Cratchits don’t praise the goose, nor do they celebrate the laundry pudding. The Ghost of Christmas Present’s feast is a dimly lit mess. No rooftop snowball fights, no games at Fred’s, and no tour of Christmas festivities around the world.
Bleak midwinter, indeed.
Contradiction: Scrooge’s misanthropy is justified
This is not the first film to give Scrooge a tragic backstory to explain his miserly ways. But no other film goes so out of its own way to do so.
In Ebenezer, Scrooge’s father is an abusive drunk who nearly drives our anti-hero to his death as a child—and this is after the change of heart that sent Little Fan to bring the boy Scrooge home. Scrooge’s beloved employer Fezziwig is murdered in the streets by a beggar. A panhandler feigns blindness in one eye to gain sympathy alms. So of course Scrooge distrusts Fred’s intentions: he’s been betrayed by his family before. And of course Scrooge doesn’t care about the poor: in his experience, they’re not just “idle”—they’re downright dangerous.
And all of this is just the stuff that happens in the actual timeline. In his tour of the alternate future, Scrooge learns that those portly gentlemen collecting funds for the poor are actually crooks with no problem using a falsified will to steal Scrooge’s estate. And who architects this sordid deal? TOPPER. Yeah, Ebenezer transforms Topper from Fred’s good-natured friend with a great set of pipes and a crush on Fred’s sister-in-law into a villainous snake who outright steals Fred’s inheritance. (Don’t worry: the “reformed” Scrooge punishes Topper with a snowball to the back of the head.)
“Isn’t that just artistic liberty, Jeffrey?” Sure. But this contradicts the real problem that the ghosts are trying to solve in Dickens’ novella. In the book, Scrooge aims “to edge his way along the crowded paths of life, warning all human sympathy to keep its distance.” Dickens never gives us a reason for Scrooge’s self-imposed isolation—because for the purposes of the story, it simply doesn’t matter. Dickens’ Scrooge is obsessed with gain and feels no responsibility to improve the lives of those around him beyond paying his taxes. There’s no traumatic event that sets Scrooge down this path: in the book, Scrooge is only a victim of himself.
To be fair, Ebenezer doesn’t let Scrooge completely off the hook. Bob Cratchit tells Scrooge that one bad apple doesn’t preclude the existence of good fruit. (Scrooge calls this a “lie,” which is, logically, stupid.) Belle tells Scrooge that he’s too focused on the shadows to see the sun. So instead of Scrooge finding redemption by seeing his fellow humans “as if they really were fellow-passengers to the grave, and not another race of creatures,” he simply allows for the possibility that maybe not everyone is out to get him. As far as reformation goes, that’s pretty weak.
Contradiction: Scrooge’s transformation is extremely limited in scope
In Stave Five of the book, a reformed Scrooge reverses every wrong he commits in Stave One:
- In Stave One, Scrooge chases away a child caroler. In Stave Five, Scrooge speaks kindly to a child and tips him handsomely for running an errand.
- In Stave One, Scrooge refuses to donate to the portly gentlemen, claiming that the state of the poor is not his business. In Stave Five, Scrooge makes a munificent donation, claiming that “a great many back-payments are included in it.”
- In Stave One, Scrooge spurns Fred’s invitation to dine with him, and belittles his marriage. In Stave Five, Scrooge humbly asks to join Fred and his niece-in-law for dinner, and revels in the festivities.
- In Stave One, Scrooge enforces harsh working conditions on Bob and threatens to fire him. In Stave Five, Scrooge surprises the Cratchits with an anonymously gifted turkey, increases Bob’s salary, promises to help his family, and finally turns up the heat in the office.
- In Stave One, Scrooge warns the whole of London to keep its distance. In Stave Five, Scrooge becomes “as good a friend, as good a master, and as good a man, as the good old city knew.”
We simply don’t see this kind of turnaround in Ebenezer. Scrooge gets the date from a boy outside his window, but (if I recall correctly) there’s no half-crown tip. The portly gentlemen, revealed as crooks by the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, are given no charity. Bob is made a partner, but Scrooge does nothing to improve the Cratchit family dinner. (In fact, there’s no turkey at all. Scrooge just brings Fred a goose.) Scrooge speaks meekly to Fred, but digs at Clara by quoting her less-than-flattering description of him (overheard during his time with the Ghost of Christmas Present). And aside from Scrooge gifting Marley’s pocket watch to a beggar, we get no indication that Scrooge will become a better friend to London.
These are all improvements on Ebenezer‘s Stave One Scrooge. But do they constitute all that much change of heart? Scrooge is kinder and more generous to Fred and Bob—the two characters the Ghost of Christmas Present revealed had toasted to his health. They’ve proven that they’re some of the good ones, and Scrooge rewards them. That’s not exactly magnanimous. As Christmas’s namesake says, “If you love those who love you, what reward will you get? Are not even the tax collectors doing that? And if you greet only your own people, what are you doing more than others? Do not even pagans do that?” (Matthew 5:46–47, NIV).
Conclusion: it could be worse
It’s another adaptation, just darker, spookier, and colder. Ebenezer tells the book’s story better than many other adaptations I’ve reviewed. But given the weird treatment of the ghosts and the underwhelming redemption arc, I doubt it’ll be a cherished classic.